Cannibalization Severity Index
Plain cannibalization tells you which queries have multiple URLs competing. The Severity Index goes further: it ranks every cannibalized query by how much it's actually costing you and assigns a one-line verdict — Merge, Re-target, or Internal-link to the winner — turning a diagnostic list into a sprint backlog.
Why it matters
A 12-URL cannibalization that earns 6 clicks/month wastes nobody's time. A 2-URL cannibalization on a query worth 1,400 clicks/month where the wrong URL is ranking is a six-figure issue. Severity puts the second one at the top and the first one at the bottom so your team works on what matters.
How rows are ordered
The report does not show a numeric score. Rows are ordered by the query's 90-day volume, and the verdict comes from three signals:
- Volume — clicks and impressions on the query over the last 90 days. Big queries come first.
- Top page share — how much of the query's clicks the winning URL already takes, and how far apart the competing URLs sit. Two URLs at positions 4 and 6 actively split clicks; positions 4 and 38 don't really compete and score lower.
- Intent mismatch — when the URL Google is currently picking is not the page you'd want to rank for the query (e.g. a blog post is outranking the product page on a transactional term), the verdict leans to Re-target.
The verdict column
- Merge — two pages cover essentially the same intent and at least one is thin. Consolidate into the stronger URL and 301 the weaker.
- Re-target — pages cover related but distinct intents and Google is confused. Rewrite titles, H1s and on-page copy so each page targets a clearly different sub-intent.
- Internal-link to winner — there is a clear winner already; the loser pages just need internal links pointing at the winner with the target anchor text to consolidate authority.
How to use it
- Work from the top of the list — it is ordered by 90-day volume, so the first ten rows are the cannibalization fixes with the largest expected click impact.
- Group by Verdict in a planning doc: Merges go to content/SEO, Re-targets to content, Internal links to dev.
- Re-run after 4–6 weeks. Fixed queries should leave the list as Google consolidates rankings on the canonical URL.
Data requirements
- GSC Performance data at query × page grain for the selected window.
- At least 28 days of history is recommended so the position spread component is stable.